Talk:Alternative words for American

Contents

1 Usian

2 Colonican

3 Usonian/Usonia/Usono

9 Do people have it backwards?

10 my opinion

Usian

I have lived in the USA for 24 years and I have not heard of this word before. Since not many people in the U.S. has heard this word before, nor my dictionary has an entry for it. Can the person who made up this word specify how this "word" is pronounced?

I tried many variations, none sounded right.

Us-Sian as in one of "us".
U-Sian as in one of "you".
U-S-sian as in U.S. of A.
U-S-ian?

Easy - just like "asian" except with a "yoo" sound.

According to Webster's standard, the dictionary editors actually maintain a citation of new words as they appeared overtime. See http://www.m-w.com/about/wordin.htm. A word earns its place in the dictionary only when it is proven to have wide-spread usage. If Wikipedia is the only place this word is invented, I would suggest we remove it. Can someone quote some citations of the usage of this word? When and where was it first used? Where did this word come from? Is it from within the US? Or is it from Europe or other part of the world?

I like the article mainly because it deals with the real issue of "An adjectival form for Citizens of the USA" which has been an issue since the 1780's. Whether it stays under this particular heading is not that important, as long as the article stays in one form or another. I have heard the term used elsewhere, and there are 1200 page links to it in google. The word also gets a mention in the faq for alt.usage.english

From Usian: "There are various reactions to this concern."

I don't think this really adds content to the page -- there are various reactions to a lot of concerns. I'd say cut it or expand it to a few sentences discussing the details of these reactions. (27 September 2001)

Now that is actually a contentful article, and probably deserves to be linked-to from American. Thank you.

--LMS

Perhaps the information should reside at America, American, or alternatives to the word American. --LMS

The above comment refers to information that was removed from this page. --LMS

Colonican

I like "Colonican." I've often thought our government had many Colonic qualities...

Yes, but when Commonwealth people refer to the "Colonies" they usually mean Australia, South Africa and/or New Zealand. You've already hijacked "American" for exclusive use, don't try and take another one :)

I think "Colonic" refers to Colon, not to colonies. Not that this is much better... --Zundark, 2001 Nov 16

I've re-added the link to American. Since the whole point of the term "Usian" is that the term "American" is ambiguous, I find it wholly appropriate that there be a link that illustrates that very ambiguity. --Dante Alighieri

What about the (quite commonly) used words "yankee" (or "yank") and "gringo"? "Yankee" may be offensive to southerners and I'm not sure if "gringo" also covers canadians. I have also been called "gringo", which is odd. Since I'm from Europe the correct term would be "vichingo". // Liftarn

Usonian/Usonia/Usono

("Usono" came _from_ Esperanto; it did not "make its way into" Esperanto. It is older than Frank Lloyd Wright's books.)

Is there data available about the etymologies of and first citations for both "Usono" and "Usonian"? Are they clearly related, or independent coinings? --Brion 06:52 Feb 5, 2003 (UTC)

I've removed it, after creating Usonia. I've read Wright's work and I tend to doubt that etymology (if you've ever tried to read any of his stuff, you'd know what I mean). If it is indeed true, there must be a source for it, but for the time being I tend to think this etymology is an assumption by an esperantist . -- Decumanus | Talk 07:22, 24 Mar 2004 (UTC)

I found an esperanto society page that suggests it was first used by Samuel Butler, the author of the utopian novel Erewhon. I'm going to go with that pending something more authoritative. -- Decumanus | Talk 08:02, 24 Mar 2004 (UTC)

I found the section on the Esperanto country name Usono misleading and unclear, and rewrote it. Here is the original text I replaced:

The Esperanto term for the United States of America is Usono. This comes from the English abbreviation U.S., which in Esperanto is pronounced OO-soh. Uso in the accusative case is uson. Thus the name for the United States in Esperanto is Usono. In Esperanto, one forms the name of a citizen of the United States using the suffix "an" which means "member of." Therefore a citizen of the United States is Usonano. Esperanto terms for the American geographic regions and people living of them are Ameriko/Amerikano, Norda Ameriko/Nordamerikano, Meza Ameriko/Mezamerikano, and Suda Ameriko/Sudamerikano.

The stuff about embedding the accusative ending onto a hypothetical form *uso is just silly. Also, there is no evidence that the Esperanto term came directly from an acronym. Such an acronymic name, if it existed, would be *Uŝao or *Uŝnao (if from Esperanto words; "ŝtato", state) or *Usao. It's generally thought to be derived from the the Wright/(Butler?) term "Usonia." --Jim Henry 20:01, 25 Aug 2004 (UTC)

Page rename

I renamed this page from Usian to Alternate words for American since it was being linked and redirected from numerous places for exactly that purpose. The more general name is more accurate as Usian is only one word covered on this page. It also makes it clear, from context, the word advocates of the terms wish to replace. Daniel Quinlan 20:26, Aug 15, 2003 (UTC)

Could you fix the double redirects your move has created? Thanks. Martin 23:18, 15 Aug 2003 (UTC)

Hey, I started fixing links and redirects, but there are a ton! (I wish there was a mass-edit to handle this sort of thing.) I'll get the rest later when I have a bit more time, but feel free to chip in. ;-) Daniel Quinlan 23:35, Aug 15, 2003 (UTC)

Done. Daniel Quinlan 04:42, Aug 16, 2003 (UTC)

estadounidense?

What would estadounidense in Latin? Maybe the Latin equivalent of estadounidense should be adopted as the neutral, "non-Monroe doctrinistic" term for Americans

The Monroe Doctrine stuff is a not very subtle POV rant, most of these words were proposed for other reasons, mostly simple pedantry, not political protest about American foreign policy. The use of "American" predates the Monroe Doctrine and the US as a global power. Daniel Quinlan 04:42, Aug 16, 2003 (UTC)

According to my Latin dict, USA is Civitates Americae Septemtrionalis Foederatae. Now give me the adjective -- Error 05:10, 16 Aug 2003 (UTC)

In my experience, usually Americanus. Latin demonyms are generally directly after the country, and this country had the poor foresight to name itself after its continent. ("United States" is no country name any more than it is for the United States of Mexico.) That said, I have seen "Statunitensis", but not often. —Muke Tever 03:40, 18 May 2005 (UTC) (a couple years late)

Knowing the work of Samuel Butler quite well I think I can say "Usian" was not invented by him.

What about "Leftpondian" (and "Rightpondian" for england), which i've seen many times on Usenet - where would that fit in the article? --Random|832 01:44, 17 Aug 2004 (UTC)

True or false??

True or false: Wikipedia can also have a list of alternate words for American as a noun meaning "a citizen of the United States". 66.245.89.130 01:27, 28 Aug 2004 (UTC)

Indigenous name(s)

I remember having read somewhere that some native american congress decided about a "common indigenous" word for america. Can someone point me to it?

Abya-Yala was the name given by the Panama Cuna to the mainland. Hence somebody decided to extend it to The Americas. -- Error 03:22, 18 Sep 2004 (UTC)

Second question: Which names were used by native americans in their languages? I think it would be nice to put this information here, too.

--Schuetzm 22:34, 17 Sep 2004 (UTC)

You'd be hard pressed to find "native" words for America (or Asia, or Africa, or Australia), since the naming of the continents, and even the concept of "continent" itself was a European conception (after all, Africa+Eurasia is a single landmass). Europeans were in an odd situation in that they didn't consider themselves to be at the center of the world. Instead, they thought Jerusalem was, so "Europe" needed a name, as did the other peninsulas of "the Continent", Africa and Asia. The Chinese, on the other hand, did think they were the center of the world, as most people do. And Americans and Australians had no concept of their continents as separate landmasses from the rest of the world until the European conquest. Any coinings in native languages since then are likely to be extremely local in distribution. Of course, if anyone can document such names, that would be fascinating! kwami 23:10, 2005 May 12 (UTC)

kwami wrote:

...after all, Africa+Eurasia is a single landmass...

Perhaps at one point it was, although there is that pesky Suez Canal separating the two. For that matter, if plate tectonics tears continental rifts between 'em, I'd put my money on their being separate continents in any event. --Ryanaxp 21:12, May 18, 2005 (UTC)

That's like saying the eastern US is a separate continent from the rest of North America because it's separated by the Mississippi River and St Lawrence Seaway (which are now connected by a canal). A canal is pretty superficial geologically. Besides, the geographic conception of Africa doesn't stop at the Suez Canal: it stops at the political boundary of Egypt, which is less than superficial geologically. kwami 05:15, 2005 May 19 (UTC)

Racist Term

I just want to point out that the term gringo - is used as a racist slang and is similar to a white person saying spic. This is from the Websters dictionary - "In Latin America the word gringo is an offensive term for a foreigner, particularly an American or English person." I can go in and edit it. By the way - I'm AMERICAN. This argument I have uncovered regarding what we should be called has seriously pissed me off. Europe and the world had no trouble distinguishing us from Canadians during WWII. There we were known as AMERICAN soldiers. By the way - I don't think that when immigrants came over to Ellis Island looking for the AMERICAN dream - they went to Colombia. --JerseyDevil 10:03, 23 Dec 2004 (UTC)

Do people have it backwards?

(This is not a criticism of this article, but rather on the idea of affixing "American" to the hemisphere and not the country.) Instead of trying to find an alternative name for nationals of the United States, wouldn't it be more logical to come up with an alternate name for residents of the hemisphere? I mean, think about how often you have to refer to people/things from the U.S., and how rarely you have to refer to the entire Americas. Seems to me like people should focus on the latter; a new coinage might have a better chance of catching on. Funnyhat 04:07, 11 Apr 2005 (UTC)

Historically the name "America" refers to the New World. You're asking all Americans to change their identity so that one American country doesn't have to bother coming up with a proper name for itself. I mean, imagine if the United States of Mexico decided to start abbreviating its name to the United States, and said that if Usonians didn't like it, they should change their country's name? There'd be a veritable fiesta of "outrage" across the USA. Or if the Third Reich had started calling itself "Europe", so that the French couldn't call themselves Europeans without implying they were German?

I doubt either choice has much chance of catching on with the general public. No US leader is going to refer to his country as anything but America, but there's no way all the other American countries are going to give it up either. This is going to remain something for the occasional individual. I just use Usonian in conversation and explain where needed. (I chose "Usonian" because I actually heard it on TV when I was a kid, and it's the only word I've ever heard.) kwami 23:25, 2005 May 12 (UTC)

my opinion

hope i'll be clear enough not to be misunderstood, since english is not my mother tongue

but to me, america means the continent, and saying united states you only mean a federation of states, as e.g. brazil or mexico are, always in the american continent.

reading the name in this way, talking about the united states of america is not one way road, and can generate incomprehensions

when you come to think about it, sounds as "the nation with capital washington d.c." is a nation without a clear name, but this doesn't mean i'm calling the inhabitant in any other way than "americans", also if ethimologically doesn't seem to be (the most) correct (name you can use)

as in the title, only my opinion))))

have a nice day,--joana 00:01, 23 Apr 2005 (UTC)

Retrieved from "https://academickids.com:443/encyclopedia/index.php/Talk:Alternative_words_for_American"