Talk:Secret Fire
|
|
I removed the name "hnau" as a description of sentient beings. It's not Tolkien's word, but C.S. Lewis'. (Out of the Silent Planet). DJ Clayworth 15:48, 20 Jan 2004 (UTC)
I'm going to add it back. Tolkien used the term in his own writings, I just created an article on hnau. Tolkien and Lewis were friends, and read and influenced each other's fiction. — Jor 15:50, 20 Jan 2004 (UTC)
- N/m the above. — Jor 16:02, 20 Jan 2004 (UTC)
Secret Fire as Holy Spirit?
I'm removing this section, as the idea of Eru as the Christian God is highly questionable. At best, it needs NPOV rewriting as one possible perspective, and I'd suggest checking out Eru_Ilúvatar, and particularly Talk:Eru_Ilúvatar, first. -- Perey 12:11, 3 Oct 2004 (UTC)
Spoiler warning (regarding Gandalf and Narya)
I hope this doesn´t sound too picky (I believe it doesn´t, since many articles regarding LOTR do have similar warnings), but this article openly mentions Gandalf wielding Narya. This is only revealed by the end of the Return of the King. The ring-bearers are a mystery till the end of the novel (with the exception of Galadriel).
What about a spoiler warning? :)