Talk:Resurrection of Jesus
|
|
| Contents |
Archives
For earlier discussion, see:
- Talk:Resurrection of Jesus Christ (archive)
- Talk:Resurrection of Jesus (archive04) - Amgine 18:08, 10 Nov 2004 (UTC)
WikiProject Jesus
In order to try to work out the relationship between all the various pages and hopefully get some consensus, I have opened a WikiProject to centralize discussion and debate. We've got several "conflicted" pages at the moment, and without centralizing discussion, it's going to get very confusing. Please join the project, if you're interested in the topic, and start discussions on the talk page. (We need to create a to-do list, but I think the current state is too conflicted to decide even that.) Mpolo 10:49, Nov 8, 2004 (UTC)
Significance of the resurrection
I've rewritten this section, mostly by merging it with Significance of Jesus' resurrection. I hope that this is an improvement. --G Rutter 16:01, 2 Dec 2004 (UTC)
How was Jesus resurrected?
According to Christian belief, God didn't raise Jesus up. This is in a way redundant. Jesus resurrected Himself, being that he is God. I have placed a "Neutrality Dispute" accordingly.
- The fact that you have a theological dispute with the resurrection itself does not justify the tag. please articulate some segment of the article which violates an articulated npov policy to justify the tag, or it will be removed accordingly. Ungtss 17:07, 24 Mar 2005 (UTC)
- The correct way to deal with an issue like this is not to add a 'disputed' tag, which inplies that the contents of the article is disputed, but to correctly report the disagreement. I'm going to remove the NPOV tag therefore. Feel free to add something about this disagreement. However I should tell you that most Christians, including theologians, are not really bothered about the distinction between "Jesus raised himself" and "God raised Jesus". For example Paul states "God raised him [Jesus] on the third day". It is considered normal in Christianity that the three persons of the Trinity have different functions. While all being God, and all One, they are not identical. DJ Clayworth 17:17, 24 Mar 2005 (UTC)