Talk:Islam and Judaism
|
|
See also: Talk:Islam and anti-Semitism
This page was originally created when someone moved the Islam and anti-Semitism article. It was then moved it back by cutting and pasting (the unfortunate side-effect of which was loss of history). Wikipedia apologises for any inconvenience this may cause.
Is this all original work? -- Zoe
- Most of it now is cut-and-pasted from the 1906 public domain Jewish Encyclopedia. It still needs a lot of editing and work. RK
The first half of this article has been emiting POV for quite sometime without any major wikifying or neutralization by the contributors. "...the most ignorant and careless minds." "...almost as credulously and rashly as any. Nor does he ever dream of verifying a quotation." Usedbook
- Good point. Will work on it. Given the points made, it is critical to address the issue of intellectual integrity, and mention must be made that many supposed quotes from the Hebrew Bible, in fact, do not exist at all. But it can be phrased more carefully, and in an NPOV fashion. RK 15:31, 5 Sep 2003 (UTC)
Why doesn't somebody add a paragraph or two about Prophet Mohammad's treatment of the Jews after they refused to follow his teachings? --Vladko 15:38, 13 Apr 2005 (UTC)