Talk:Docking
From Academic Kids
I wrote: "Show dogs of many breeds are still routinely docked in the UK." and miss-spelt "routinely". My spell checker corrected it to: "Show dogs of many breeds are still rottenly docked in the UK." - which sums up my views quite well I think ;) Which is another way of saying - "please check for NPOV"
I've tried for a pro/anti balance in the links, but they are rather UK centred so some more worldwide links would also be useful
The article is rather dog based too (not surprising considering the first two authors). Maybe this needs more on docking in other animals too (sheep? pigs?) but most of the discussion on the subject relates to dogs so I'm not sure what we can say on that subject.
-- sannse (talk) 23:03, 3 May 2004 (UTC)
- Just N-pov'd the 'criticisms' section and pegged it to two published sources. The preceding version asserted some of the critical argument's evidence as if to treat it as fact. Since all those claims about animal behaviour and physiology are reputably in dispute, I think it's fairest to 'outsource' the disagreement, with plenty of reference. Adhib 16:55, 27 Jan 2005 (UTC)
